Build on Strengths. Hire for the Gaps.

Chefs work at different stations in a professional restaurant kitchen, each handling a separate part of the meal.

A company has a sales leader who opens new markets, wins business, and earns her team's respect. Revenue keeps growing.

She's not particularly strong at building processes or the systems a larger sales organization needs. So the company builds her a development plan: operational training, closer attention to reporting, coaching on what she doesn't do well.

None of that is wrong. But it misses a more important question: Is the company helping a strong leader become more effective, or trying to turn her into someone she's not?

And one it hasn't asked at all: Should those operational capabilities come from her?

Not Every Weakness Needs to Be Fixed

Most organizations pay close attention to performance gaps. Annual reviews point out areas to improve, leadership assessments highlight development needs, and coaching plans focus on what someone is missing. That focus exists for good reason. Weaknesses that interfere with a leader's core responsibilities have to be addressed.

But not every weakness carries the same consequences.

A CFO who struggles with financial judgment has a serious problem. A CFO who isn't especially charismatic in front of large groups may be fine, provided they communicate well with the people who depend on their decisions. A VP of Sales who can't manage a forecast or hold people accountable can't delegate those responsibilities away. On the other hand, a talented sales leader who needs help with systems or analytics might benefit more from complementary talent than from another round of operational coaching.

The distinction is between a weakness that prevents someone from succeeding and one that can be managed without compromising results. Too often, companies treat both as development priorities.

That has a cost. Time spent taking a leader from mediocre to adequate in an area that isn't central to their value is time not spent helping them get even better at what they do best. For example, a leader who is great at opening markets can often add more value by building customer relationships or partnerships, rather than by becoming a passable administrator.

This doesn't mean lowering standards. It means being deliberate about where development efforts will have the biggest impact.

The goal isn't to eliminate every individual weakness. It's to make sure the organization as a whole has the capabilities it needs to succeed.

The Leadership Team Matters More Than the Individual Scorecard

An executive can be highly capable and still be the wrong addition to a particular leadership team.

Imagine a CEO surrounded by strong strategists. The team has no shortage of ideas, market insight, or ambitious growth plans. What it lacks is someone who can turn those plans into consistent execution. Another visionary, even an exceptional one, may add less value than a disciplined operator who builds systems, establishes accountability, and follows through.

The reverse is equally true. A company with excellent operational discipline may need someone willing to challenge established assumptions, spot new opportunities, and take calculated risks.

Neither type of leader is inherently better. Their value depends on what the business already has and what it needs. That is where strengths-based thinking becomes useful. Instead of measuring every leader against the same idealized profile, organizations can look at how capabilities combine across the team: where they are already strong, what is missing, and whether development efforts are making people more effective or simply making everyone look alike.

That view applies to existing executives as much as prospective hires. It also helps leaders see the difference between a development need and a hiring need.

Hire for What the Business Is Missing

Executive hiring usually begins with a vacancy. Someone leaves, a new role is approved, or the company reaches a point where it needs more leadership capacity. In our experience, the job description that follows is often based on either the person who had the job before or a generic idea of what a strong executive should be.

Neither starts with the team that person will join.

Suppose a company is hiring a COO. The CEO is a strong relationship builder and strategic thinker. The CFO brings financial discipline and analytical rigor. Department leaders know their markets and customers. What the organization needs most is someone who can turn decisions into action, establish consistent operating practices, and create accountability across functions. That gap should shape the search from the first conversation.

It often doesn't, and the reason usually shows up in the interview process.

Hiring committees can be drawn to strengths they recognize in themselves. A leadership team full of strategists may find the most strategic candidate the most impressive person in the room. In an interview, a candidate who talks compellingly about strategy can make a stronger impression than someone whose real strength is executing it. The disciplined operator can come across as the weaker candidate, even when they are the stronger fit.

Committees also tend to compare candidates to each other instead of focusing on the gap they need to fill. The discussion becomes about who is strongest overall, not who brings what the team lacks. That's how companies end up hiring someone with the same capabilities they already have.

Research supports looking past titles and pedigree toward what candidates can actually do. SHRM's 2026 Skills-First Movement study found that organizations able to assess candidates' proficiency in job-relevant skills were more likely to meet or exceed their financial objectives than those without that ability: 63% compared with 51%. The finding doesn't prove that skills assessment alone drives performance, and it isn't specific to executive hiring. It does reinforce the value of evaluating capability deliberately rather than relying on credentials or familiar career paths.

At the senior level, we'd take that further. A candidate's strengths are important, but so is how those strengths fit with the rest of the team.

The practical fix starts before the first interview. Name the capability the team is missing and write it into the evaluation criteria. Brief every member of the hiring committee on it, so each interviewer is assessing the same gap rather than their own idea of a strong executive. Then hold the debrief to that standard.

The best executive hire isn't necessarily the most well-rounded candidate. It's the one whose capabilities make the whole leadership team stronger.

Development, Delegation, or a New Hire?

Not every gap calls for the same solution.

When a leader lacks capabilities essential to the role, those gaps have to be addressed. The organization can't compensate for them indefinitely. Other weaknesses can be managed by delegating or shifting responsibilities. Sometimes, the missing capability is important enough that hiring someone new is the best answer.

Consider the sales leader from the opening. If she can't hold her team accountable or make good business decisions, those issues need to be addressed directly. But if she's getting great results and the real problem is the company's lack of operational support, coaching her to be an administrator might not be the best use of time. The answer may be an experienced sales operations leader, a different division of responsibilities, or someone already on the team who could take on that work. Companies often have more capability in their existing workforce than they realize.

Before spending a lot of time fixing an executive's weaknesses or starting a new search, leadership teams should consider three things: what the person does well, what the role truly needs, and what capabilities already exist in the organization.

Build a Stronger Team, Not a Collection of Perfect Individuals

There's nothing wrong with helping leaders improve. The willingness to recognize limitations and build new capabilities is part of effective leadership.

But improvement shouldn't automatically mean more time on weaknesses. Sometimes it means investing more deeply in exceptional strengths. Sometimes it means giving a talented executive the support to concentrate on the work where they create the most value. And sometimes it means accepting that the business needs a capability no one on the team has, and hiring for it on purpose.

The same logic that argues for reconsidering candidates who don't check every box applies after the hire, when companies develop leaders and shape teams.

One person doesn't have to be exceptional at everything. The leadership team, taken together, does have to be capable of delivering what the business expects. The companies that get this right stop asking whether each leader is well-rounded and start asking what the leadership team, as a whole, still lacks.

Questions Leaders Often Ask

Ken Schmitt

Ken Schmitt is Partner & Co-Founder of Ascentria Search Partners. With nearly 30 years of executive search experience, he advises private, founder-led, and private equity-backed companies on leadership hiring, talent strategy, succession planning, and organizational growth. Ken is the author of The Practical Optimist, founder of the Sales & Marketing Leadership Alliance (SMLA), and publisher of the Hiring Matters newsletter.

https://www.ascentriasearch.com/ken-schmitt
Next
Next

Year-End Burnout and the Leadership It Takes to Finish Strong